Sheffield Wednesday host Plymouth Argyle at Hillsborough on 14 November 2026 in what amounts to a straightforward contrast in managerial stability. Wednesday sit ninth after 13 games, Plymouth fifth and Dave Challinor is stepping into his first league game in charge against a Plymouth side Tom Cleverley has been shaping since July 2025. Sixteen months of work against a first week in the job: that gap probably tells you more about the likely outcome than any recent form line does.
Challinor walked into a squad that had been operating under Henrik Pedersen until early November, whereas Cleverley has had 16 months to get his ideas across and his personnel settled. Wednesday have been winless in their last four or five league games, having drawn 1-1 with Blackpool on 1 November before the cup results made things worse: an FA Cup loss to Oldham around 8 November was followed by a heavy EFL Trophy defeat to Accrington Stanley near 12 November. Plymouth have been steadier, having drawn 0-0 at Reading on 31 October and picked up wins against Cambridge and Wimbledon, though they dropped points against Huddersfield and Stevenage along the way. The visitors come in on 23 points from around 14 games and will see this trip as a chance to close the gap on the top two.

Challinor is working with a heavily patched squad: Joe Lumley and Ashley Maynard-Brewer are both unavailable in goal, Tyler Onyango is a long term absentee with a cruciate injury, Max Lowe is out four to six weeks with a hamstring problem and Sil Swinkels is suspended, while the unavailability of Louie Barry, Reece James, Liam Cooper, Ali Al-Hamadi, Mason Burstow and Billy Mitchell thins things out further. Plymouth are without Michael Baidoo through a hamstring recurrence and Aribim Pepple through injury, with Joe Edwards a doubt and Kieran Morrison away on international duty.
Challinor's early messaging has been about organisation, with Barry Bannan central to that, anchoring midfield and setting the tempo against a Plymouth side that likes to push the pace. Keillor-Dunn has been finding the net and will be an outlet going forward, though the defensive absences will almost certainly stop Wednesday from pressing high, leaving them to sit compact and look to frustrate Plymouth before hunting set piece openings.
Plymouth play with discipline and are effective on the counter, with Will Evans leading the attack and Xavier Amaechi working in behind him while Harvey White sits and screens in front of Plymouth's back line. With Baidoo and Pepple both out, Amaechi will need to do more in tight spaces while Evans tries to hold play up against a reorganised Wednesday defence. The battle between Bannan and White feels like the central question of the game: if Bannan wins second balls, Wednesday can build, if White and Amaechi click, Plymouth will find space to exploit on the break.
Plymouth's forward line being thinner without Baidoo and Pepple may push Cleverley toward a more patient approach and give Wednesday time to settle, so expect Wednesday to recycle through Bannan early as they try to establish some midfield foothold while Plymouth wait for moments to release Evans and Amaechi in behind.

Plymouth hold a slight edge in wins across 16 previous meetings, though those results span different divisions and tell you little about what happens here. With both defences disrupted by absentees, set pieces could easily decide this: Wednesday will look for delivery angles from Bannan and Keillor-Dunn on attacking restarts, while Plymouth tend to get value from dead balls when Evans can attack crosses. A lapse of concentration at a corner or free kick from either side may be all it takes.
Plymouth to win 1-2. Led by Evans and Amaechi on the counter, they should take three points even if Wednesday make it uncomfortable, with Challinor's depleted back line and 16 month head start in the dugout making the difference. Challinor's side may get something through Bannan's midfield work or a moment from Keillor-Dunn but not enough to change the result on what is about as hard a first league game as a new manager could ask for.

Ryan Baldi
Football Writer
Ryan Baldi is a professional football writer with years of experience and has been featured by respected outlets such as the BBC, The Guardian, Sky Sports, DAZN, FourFourTwo, ESPN, Yahoo Sport and Football365. He has also written several books including Arsène Who?.
