Head-to-head overview

Based on the matches in our database.

Barnsley 73 draws5 Plymouth Argyle
15
Meetings
3.07
Goals / game
47%
Both teams scored
73%
Over 2.5 goals
Barnsley

Facts about Barnsley

Scored in10/15 (67%)
Conceded in11/15 (73%)
Goals scored24 · 1.6/game
Longest winning streak2
Longest unbeaten run3
Longest losing streak2
Longest run without a win3
Plymouth Argyle

Facts about Plymouth Argyle

Scored in11/15 (73%)
Conceded in10/15 (67%)
Goals scored22 · 1.47/game
Longest winning streak2
Longest unbeaten run3
Longest losing streak2
Longest run without a win3
By competition
CompetitionBarnsleyDrawPlymouth ArgyleGames
Championship4228
League One3137
All competitions73515

ELO comparison

Five-year rating histories overlaid, with a neutral head-to-head forecast.

Barnsley1565
gap 148
1713Plymouth Argyle
1734156320222023202420252026
If they met (neutral venue)
Barnsley
18%
Draw
24%
Plymouth Argyle
58%

All meetings

15 matches on record

12 Sep 2026
League One
Plymouth ArgylePlymouth Argyle3–0BarnsleyBarnsley
BTTSO2.5
6 Apr 2026
League One
BarnsleyBarnsley0–3Plymouth ArgylePlymouth Argyle
BTTSO2.5
2 Aug 2025
League One
Plymouth ArgylePlymouth Argyle1–3BarnsleyBarnsley
BTTSO2.5

Barnsley recent form

Plymouth Argyle recent form

Barnsley has gone head to head with Plymouth Argyle 15 times since 2006, winning 7 and scoring 24 goals. Plymouth Argyle, in turn, has won 5 and scored 22 goals. There have been 3 draws between Barnsley and Plymouth Argyle. Across all meetings both teams have scored in 47% of games and 73% have produced over 2.5 goals, at an average of 3.07 goals per game.