Latest meeting
US Open Cup7 May
FT
Brooklyn Italians1447+113
NY Cosmos1496-112Next meeting
No fixture scheduled.
Head-to-head overview
Based on the matches in our database.
Brooklyn Italians 10 draws1 NY Cosmos
2
Meetings
3.5
Goals / game
50%
Both teams scored
50%
Over 2.5 goals
Facts about Brooklyn Italians
Scored in1/2 (50%)
Conceded in2/2 (100%)
Goals scored3 · 1.5/game
Longest winning streak1
Longest unbeaten run1
Longest losing streak1
Longest run without a win1
Facts about NY Cosmos
Scored in2/2 (100%)
Conceded in1/2 (50%)
Goals scored4 · 2/game
Longest winning streak1
Longest unbeaten run1
Longest losing streak1
Longest run without a win1
By competition
| Competition | Brooklyn Italians | Draw | NY Cosmos | Games |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| US Open Cup | 1 | 0 | 1 | 2 |
| All competitions | 1 | 0 | 1 | 2 |
ELO comparison
Five-year rating histories overlaid, with a neutral head-to-head forecast.
Brooklyn Italians1448
gap 141434NY Cosmos
If they met (neutral venue)
Brooklyn Italians
37%
Draw
30%
NY Cosmos
33%
All meetings
2 matches on record
Brooklyn Italians recent form
Last 5 matches
US Open CupUS Open CupUS Open CupUS Open CupUS Open Cup
10/05/2018
FT
0Brooklyn Italians1458-12
Brooklyn Italians1458-122
Lansdowne Bhoys1515+12
Lansdowne Bhoys1515+1207/05/2018
FT
3Brooklyn Italians1447+11
Brooklyn Italians1447+112NY Cosmos1496-11
NY Cosmos1496-1113/05/2015
FT
3
Long Island Rough Riders1502+12
Long Island Rough Riders1502+121Brooklyn Italians1460-12
Brooklyn Italians1460-1228/05/2014
FT
2NY Cosmos1500+12
NY Cosmos1500+120Brooklyn Italians1472-12
Brooklyn Italians1472-1215/05/2014
FT
2
Jersey Express1500-17
Jersey Express1500-174Brooklyn Italians1456+17
Brooklyn Italians1456+17Next 5 matches
No upcoming fixtures.
NY Cosmos recent form
Last 5 matches
USL League OneUSL League OneUSL League OneUSL League OneUSL League One
12/09/2026
FT
2
Boise1565+6
Boise1565+61New York Cosmos1440-6
New York Cosmos1440-605/09/2026
FT
2
Fort Wayne1538-19
Fort Wayne1538-194New York Cosmos1421+19
New York Cosmos1421+1902/09/2026
FT
1New York Cosmos1430-9
New York Cosmos1430-92
Sarasota Paradise1482+9
Sarasota Paradise1482+930/08/2026
FT
1
Union Omaha1611-5
Union Omaha1611-51New York Cosmos1422+5
New York Cosmos1422+522/08/2026
FT
3
Chattanooga Red Wolves1534-4
Chattanooga Red Wolves1534-43New York Cosmos1418+4
New York Cosmos1418+4Next 5 matches
USL League OneNew York Cosmos1434
Westchester SC1432USL League OneNew York Cosmos1434
Richmond Kickers1403USL League One
FC Naples1445New York Cosmos1434USL League One
Charlotte Independ.1604New York Cosmos1434USL League OneNew York Cosmos1434
One Knoxville1594
19/09/2026
23:00
New York Cosmos1434Westchester SC143226/09/2026
23:00
New York Cosmos1434Richmond Kickers140303/10/2026
23:00
FC Naples1445New York Cosmos143410/10/2026
23:00
Charlotte Independ.1604New York Cosmos143417/10/2026
20:00
New York Cosmos1434One Knoxville1594Brooklyn Italians has gone head to head with NY Cosmos 2 times since 2014, winning 1 and scoring 3 goals. NY Cosmos, in turn, has won 1 and scored 4 goals. None of their meetings have ended level. Across all meetings both teams have scored in 50% of games and 50% have produced over 2.5 goals, at an average of 3.5 goals per game.