Head-to-head overview

Based on the matches in our database.

Cincinnati 74 draws10 New York City
21
Meetings
3.57
Goals / game
57%
Both teams scored
67%
Over 2.5 goals
Cincinnati

Facts about Cincinnati

Scored in16/21 (76%)
Conceded in16/21 (76%)
Goals scored32 · 1.52/game
Longest winning streak5
Longest unbeaten run7
Longest losing streak6
Longest run without a win8
New York City

Facts about New York City

Scored in16/21 (76%)
Conceded in16/21 (76%)
Goals scored43 · 2.05/game
Longest winning streak6
Longest unbeaten run8
Longest losing streak5
Longest run without a win7
By competition
CompetitionCincinnatiDrawNew York CityGames
MLS541019
Leagues Cup1001
US Open Cup1001
All competitions741021

ELO comparison

Five-year rating histories overlaid, with a neutral head-to-head forecast.

Cincinnati1746
gap 37
1709New York City
1816146220222023202420252026
If they met (neutral venue)
Cincinnati
40%
Draw
30%
New York City
30%

All meetings

21 matches on record

19 Aug 2026
MLS
CincinnatiCincinnati21New York CityNew York City
BTTSO2.5
22 Apr 2026
MLS
New York CityNew York City44CincinnatiCincinnati
BTTSO2.5
23 Aug 2025
MLS
CincinnatiCincinnati01New York CityNew York City
BTTSO2.5
4 May 2025
MLS
New York CityNew York City10CincinnatiCincinnati
BTTSO2.5

Cincinnati recent form

New York City recent form

Cincinnati has gone head to head with New York City 21 times since 2019, winning 7 and scoring 32 goals. New York City, in turn, has won 10 and scored 43 goals. There have been 4 draws between Cincinnati and New York City. Across all meetings both teams have scored in 57% of games and 67% have produced over 2.5 goals, at an average of 3.57 goals per game.