Latest meeting
MLS22 Jul
FT
Columbus Crew1743-111
New York City1737+112Next meeting
No fixture scheduled.
Head-to-head overview
Based on the matches in our database.
Columbus Crew 128 draws11 New York City
31
Meetings
3.29
Goals / game
71%
Both teams scored
65%
Over 2.5 goals
Facts about Columbus Crew
Scored in24/31 (77%)
Conceded in28/31 (90%)
Goals scored49 · 1.58/game
Longest winning streak3
Longest unbeaten run7
Longest losing streak2
Longest run without a win4
Facts about New York City
Scored in28/31 (90%)
Conceded in24/31 (77%)
Goals scored53 · 1.71/game
Longest winning streak2
Longest unbeaten run4
Longest losing streak3
Longest run without a win7
By competition
| Competition | Columbus Crew | Draw | New York City | Games |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| MLS | 11 | 7 | 11 | 29 |
| US Open Cup | 1 | 0 | 0 | 1 |
| Leagues Cup | 0 | 1 | 0 | 1 |
| All competitions | 12 | 8 | 11 | 31 |
ELO comparison
Five-year rating histories overlaid, with a neutral head-to-head forecast.
Columbus Crew1699
gap 251724New York City
If they met (neutral venue)
Columbus Crew
32%
Draw
30%
New York City
38%
All meetings
31 matches on record
Columbus Crew recent form
Last 5 matches
MLSMLSMLSMLSLeagues Cup
12/09/2026
FT
0Columbus Crew1711-12
Columbus Crew1711-121
New York Red Bulls1648+12
New York Red Bulls1648+1209/09/2026
FT
2
DC United1638+12
DC United1638+121Columbus Crew1723-12
Columbus Crew1723-1205/09/2026
FT
3Columbus Crew1706+17
Columbus Crew1706+170
Colorado Rapids1723-17
Colorado Rapids1723-1730/08/2026
FT
1Columbus Crew1722-16
Columbus Crew1722-163
New England Revolution1686+16
New England Revolution1686+1627/08/2026
FT
2
Club America1821+13
Club America1821+130Columbus Crew1735-13
Columbus Crew1735-13
New York City recent form
Last 5 matches
Columbus Crew has gone head to head with New York City 31 times since 2015, winning 12 and scoring 49 goals. New York City, in turn, has won 11 and scored 53 goals. There have been 8 draws between Columbus Crew and New York City. Across all meetings both teams have scored in 71% of games and 65% have produced over 2.5 goals, at an average of 3.29 goals per game.