Head-to-head overview

Based on the matches in our database.

Columbus Crew 1811 draws13 Toronto
42
Meetings
2.93
Goals / game
57%
Both teams scored
52%
Over 2.5 goals
Columbus Crew

Facts about Columbus Crew

Scored in34/42 (81%)
Conceded in30/42 (71%)
Goals scored65 · 1.55/game
Longest winning streak4
Longest unbeaten run10
Longest losing streak3
Longest run without a win5
Toronto

Facts about Toronto

Scored in30/42 (71%)
Conceded in34/42 (81%)
Goals scored58 · 1.38/game
Longest winning streak3
Longest unbeaten run5
Longest losing streak4
Longest run without a win10
By competition
CompetitionColumbus CrewDrawTorontoGames
MLS17111341
Club Friendlies1001
All competitions18111342

ELO comparison

Five-year rating histories overlaid, with a neutral head-to-head forecast.

Columbus Crew1790
gap 119
1671Toronto
1912152420222023202420252026
If they met (neutral venue)
Columbus Crew
53%
Draw
26%
Toronto
21%

All meetings

42 matches on record

24 Oct 2026
MLS
Columbus CrewColumbus Crew4–2TorontoToronto
BTTSO2.5
21 Mar 2026
MLS
TorontoToronto2–1Columbus CrewColumbus Crew
BTTSO2.5
20 Sep 2025
MLS
Columbus CrewColumbus Crew1–1TorontoToronto
BTTSO2.5
16 Aug 2025
MLS
TorontoToronto1–1Columbus CrewColumbus Crew
BTTSO2.5

Columbus Crew recent form

Toronto recent form

Columbus Crew has gone head to head with Toronto 42 times since 2010, winning 18 and scoring 65 goals. Toronto, in turn, has won 13 and scored 58 goals. There have been 11 draws between Columbus Crew and Toronto. Across all meetings both teams have scored in 57% of games and 52% have produced over 2.5 goals, at an average of 2.93 goals per game.