Head-to-head overview

Based on the matches in our database.

New York City 139 draws9 Toronto
31
Meetings
3.26
Goals / game
58%
Both teams scored
58%
Over 2.5 goals
New York City

Facts about New York City

Scored in24/31 (77%)
Conceded in25/31 (81%)
Goals scored52 · 1.68/game
Longest winning streak6
Longest unbeaten run8
Longest losing streak2
Longest run without a win6
Toronto

Facts about Toronto

Scored in25/31 (81%)
Conceded in24/31 (77%)
Goals scored49 · 1.58/game
Longest winning streak2
Longest unbeaten run6
Longest losing streak6
Longest run without a win8
By competition
CompetitionNew York CityDrawTorontoGames
MLS129930
Leagues Cup1001
All competitions139931

ELO comparison

Five-year rating histories overlaid, with a neutral head-to-head forecast.

New York City1709
gap 18
1691Toronto
1793152420222023202420252026
If they met (neutral venue)
New York City
38%
Draw
30%
Toronto
32%

All meetings

31 matches on record

29 Aug 2026
MLS
TorontoToronto11New York CityNew York City
BTTSO2.5
31 Jul 2026
MLS
New York CityNew York City11TorontoToronto
BTTSO2.5
3 Jul 2025
MLS
New York CityNew York City31TorontoToronto
BTTSO2.5
26 Apr 2025
MLS
TorontoToronto01New York CityNew York City
BTTSO2.5

New York City recent form

Toronto recent form

New York City has gone head to head with Toronto 31 times since 2015, winning 13 and scoring 52 goals. Toronto, in turn, has won 9 and scored 49 goals. There have been 9 draws between New York City and Toronto. Across all meetings both teams have scored in 58% of games and 58% have produced over 2.5 goals, at an average of 3.26 goals per game.